Leeds Banter Archive December 22 2011

 

Use our rumours form to send us leeds transfer rumours.

22 Dec 2011 23:31:50
What do you guys think about Jordan Rhodes? He would probably cost top £££. Would he be too much of a risk? Billy Paynter scored 30 goals at League 1 level, would it be a similar situation?

Believable1 Unbelievable0

50:50 Adam le fondre is doing alright at Reading but he could become another billy paynter

Agree1 Disagree0

Different type of player, Paynter got his goals by bullying the weaker defences of League 1 whereas he isn't strong enough or fast enough to do the same in the Championship. Rhodes is far more cultured so is more than capable of making the leap

Agree1 Disagree0

Le Fondre is a great player, much better than paynter as hes actually scored more than one goal at this level

Agree0 Disagree1

Plus Alfie played in league 2 and has made a good start to the step up

Agree0 Disagree1

22 Dec 2011 21:03:03
Just a long shot and me being suspicous, but since the away fans have been out priced and moved into cardboard cutout stand, it appears to have given the away team a bigger incentive to win. If I were a manager/player I would want to prove a point more than ever in beating us for the few that have made the trip and show that we are an overpriced, average team! The atmosphere has gone and even where I am in N9 the Kop it has lost its voice! Like I said it may be a way, way off theory and no I havnt been sniffing ths sherry but may turn into an alcoholic if we dont improve!

MOT

Believable5 Unbelievable1

I started my Xmas brandy bottle after the Barnsley game.

Agree1 Disagree0

Well I'm in N11 for Burnley so a few good chants might get started (lets start now)

We all love Leeds and Leeds and Leeds...

Agree1 Disagree1

I cannot understand the reasoning in moving the away fans. Away support has diminished due to the high ticket prices in West Stand; Atmosphere dreadful (no banter in West Stand between home and away) and Elland Road is becoming more like a soulless, sanitised premiership ground rather than the famed atmospheric stadium we used to have. Away fans moved and performances suddenly drop- is there any link?

Agree0 Disagree0

22 Dec 2011 18:08:33
MY god people! Ken bates owns Leeds united and elland road what is the matter with you lot!

Believable2 Unbelievable4

Umm i think everyone no's that fella. And nout the matter with me but thanks for asking !!!!

Agree4 Disagree1

22 Dec 2011 17:09:39
i dont think grayson is the man to take us back into the premiership but with the limited funds and 2nd rate players we seem to buy... who could do better?

Believable4 Unbelievable1

Er,who do you thinks buying the second rate players ,doh.

Agree4 Disagree3

Lonergan, mccormack, clayton, kis (when we first got him), somma on his day is a very good striker, sam doesnt do too bad in the right position, theyre not 2nd rate players in my view, every manager makes crap signings thats the world of football

Agree1 Disagree0

22 Dec 2011 16:18:57
Why do so many people want grayson gone!

You're stupid if you ask me!

Believable5 Unbelievable8

To ask that question means that you either don't go to games or you don't know much about football! Which one is it?

Agree9 Disagree8

Many people want Grayson gone because he can't win home games.

Agree7 Disagree3

But were still 6th in league and its easier to change home form than it is to change away form.

Agree3 Disagree6

To the first response, you must have no patience whatsoever

Agree0 Disagree2

22 Dec 2011 16:13:38
How can anyone on here call our fans a disgrace the only person you can say that to is the man that love to lie to the fans and that bates saying to leeds fans stay patient he says that every window to try and keep us on his side bye bye bates you've done enough of making our club out to be just one big joke

Believable3 Unbelievable4

Bye bye? You know of a buyer then? No other way he's going anywhere.

Agree1 Disagree1

22 Dec 2011 15:57:32
We have to question why Bates is spending money on a stadium we dont even own. Surely it is better to spend money on improving the team. We are a Football club first & foremost & promotion should be our main priority, if we are promoted we can then develop the ground further.
I am fed up with listening/hearing Bates blame everybody but himself....how much have we spent this year? . If we are to compete we have to spend more than the 300k we spent on Lonners, we only need to look at Norwich & Swansea to see what can be achieved with a little investment.

Believable1 Unbelievable2

That's like saying the same for Man City you have no business acumen and that shows

Agree1 Disagree1

If you listened to what Bates is saying you wouldnt post crap like this,the banks wont lend money to buy players,whereas they will for redevelopment,he may not be everybodys cup of tea,but hes a shrewd buisinessman,the loanees are out there,if SG brought a few decent players in instead of the Rachubkas etc,be much nearer promotion.

Agree4 Disagree2

Bates is spending money on a stadium we don't even own because the owner of the stadium is the same owner of LUFC. Bates! Told people this many times. Bates will sell the ground and Thorp Arch back to LUFC after the 2012 Olympics once property prices go back up. Nice bit of profit for Papa Smurf.

Agree0 Disagree1

No you speak "crap" as you so eloquently put it. The original poster is correct to question the motive behind spending on a stadium that we do not own. What collateral has Bates put against the loan to pay for the redevelopment seen as Leeds Utd does not have any assets other than the company itself. You CANNOT get a loan without the bank having some insurance for if you cannot pay back the money in the current economic climate. If the loan is in Leeds Utd's name (which it will be to prevent him from being liable if the loan cannot be repaid, due to him not owning all of it) then the club would be liquidated to pay back the loan after the bank has seized it. It is therefore unethical to put the club into a position of debt, especially when we don't own Elland Road and the rent is increasing every year. (If I rented a field with the consent of the council for planning permission. Would a bank allow me a loan to build a house on it, despite the fact the land belonged to someone else and they would not be able to seize the property if i went bankrupt due to it belonging to the landlord? I think not.)
This is not the work of shrewd business man. It is either a foolish or fraudulent move. If he does not own the stadium then we are wasting money as the owner can sell Elland Road for much more if we fail to use the buy back clause (and to anyone), while we will be left with the debt for something we can no longer use. If he DOES own the stadium(??) then its for tax evasion purposes as he can write off the rent against the clubs tax bill and pocket the money thus making a profit and avoiding giving the tax man more money. Also when new owners take over he will be able to sell Elland Road too them, but at a highly inflated price due to the work he has had done (however the new owners will be left with the debt for the work as well, thus giving Bates a tidy profit)

Agree5 Disagree1

Swnsea spent more on players than we did

Agree3 Disagree1

Just out of interest, what would bates be gaining at the minute from ownership of elland road and thorp arch? I might be a bit naive, but surely if as owner of leeds united he is paying rent to himself for using the ground etc then is it not just like shifting cash around his own bank accounts, as technically as the owner of leeds all profits the club makes belongs to him unless he sees fit to not take it? I might be being a bit simple, but is he not as owner of leeds united and sole investor entitled to any and all profits i would have thought?
By the way not saying it's right if he takes all the profits, just trying to understand the ownership/money situation.

Agree0 Disagree0

In regards to the last post - Bates owns 71% of Leeds the rest is owned by an offshore company who's owners are not named due to them owning less than 10% each of the said company (the structure is on LUFC website).
Bates, whilst majority shareholder, cannot help himself to the profits, but he can take the rent which he can pocket. Its good for the business as well as it costs Leeds less in tax as the rent can be written off as expenses against Leeds Utd's tax bill so therefore the club makes a saving and he can put the money back into the club if he wants, thereby making it a money saving exercise. (Remember Bates lives in a tax haven and does not like the tax man taking his "hard earned" cash)

Agree2 Disagree0

22 Dec 2011 15:27:09
Good to see Bates announcing home form must improve or SG will be sacked. Right move in my opinion. This can't go on like this. Unfair on SG because he has not had the money to spend but I think the real problem is that his backroom staff (Miller and Snodin) are not quite good enough to take us into the Premiership. I blame poor home form on all 3 personnel rather than just Grayson.

Source: Sky Sports

Believable5 Unbelievable3

Agree with your post in the main except the money part Grayson has had money to spend, & he has had money from the sales of players he has said both publicly.

Agree3 Disagree1

Us fans have to take some blame. the players go out at ER just waiting for the boo boys to start.

Agree4 Disagree4

22 Dec 2011 14:41:05
Answers on a post card please if we Leeds fans are so good why is it that our players are looking for comfort away from Elland Road, rather than us the fans making it a fortress we have made it uncomfortable for our own players to play there. Time the boo boys stopped and time the bates out campaign realised that match days are not the place of there campaign. We are Leeds but at the moment we the fans need to take some blame for the current situation, lets take Elland road back and make at positive place for our players and stick it to the away team.

Believable8 Unbelievable0

So the reason the team has underperformed this season is because of the fans???

Agree0 Disagree2

That and Graysons inept managerial skills yes. You have to take into account a first team players opinion that he made today so yes it is affecting the team.

Agree3 Disagree1

Comfortable away from home? Watford anyone?

Agree1 Disagree0

Do you not think the fans are divided because of the lack of investment in players & the continue promise of money for new players....if we have money lets see it & see what SG does then.

Agree2 Disagree1

Re 'lets see it & lets see what SG does then' well he has had it for years he has said so himself, you have already seen what he has done sfa

Agree2 Disagree2

Stats so far played 25 games 12 away from home and 13 at home:

Record Away lost 3 Drawn 3 won 6

Record Home lost 5 drawn 2 won 6

Clearly we are better away from home has we have picked up more points away yet we have played more at home, home grounds typically are where teams pick up the majority of our points not the case currently for Leeds.

Agree2 Disagree0

The away support with Leeds is far better than the home support - putting away supporters in the West Stand contributed to the poor atmosphere at Elland Road us Leeds fans thrive off the banter of good away support so lets get em back in the cheese wedge at normal prices

Agree1 Disagree0

This is such crap. Under performing? No. We have a worse team than last year arguably and we are a place higher than where we finished.

Agree0 Disagree1

22 Dec 2011 14:33:40
ken bates really is a plantpot. stating we need to go up or grayson gets the axe and that becchio is the reason we have misfired???

to me he is suggesting the following with his recent statements

players will be sold on the cheap and there will be no major movement to the team as he is not wanting to invest his pension on our promotion, grayson is in a no win situation as he wont have the funds he would like to bring in the quality and becchio will be sold as bates is already bad mouthing him in his paper the YEP whic only writes what papa smurf allows......

Believable5 Unbelievable3

Ken Bates is far from a plant pot, the fans want public interaction then when they get it they call him a plantpot you are a disgrace. No player has been sold on the cheap why would he do that. You want the truth bates gives you it then you still moan, when he says nothing you moan he cant win why because he is Ken Bates, tell me with facts what is it that Ken bates has done that requires for him to leave in disgrace, I don't want conjecture I want true facts, hit me with something. Leeds are making a financial profit we are investing in our youth system we are investing in commercial & corporate departments that will bring future revenue and security for our club for years to come. You all forget that Simon Grayson has said publically he has revenue he is happy with it, he has also been given money from player sales what more can Bates do if Simon Grayson chooses not to spend that money is that Bates fault for the plantpot rose tinted brigade yes it is for anyone with common sense who can see the bigger picture it is clear that the manager gets a free ride while all pressure is put on Bates. Lots of people on here complain about wage cap there is no such wage cap or ceiling price Grayson and Harvey have a financial budget that is amongst the highest in the league yet people criticise bates for not paying enough wages do you want to be run like Bristol City? Really to remind you debts of £11.45m after tax for the last tax year losses of £11.8m the year before and loses of £6.5m for 2009 thats £29.75m in 3 years now if bates was doing this to Leeds then fair play moan. I don’t understand the complaints that our club holding companies are registered in tax havens shock horror this makes business sense we spend less money on HMRC would you rather we pay them money I wouldn’t, the majority of high street businesses are set up in exactly the same way.

Agree4 Disagree2

Beckford,johnson,kilkenny- free agents, think thats on the cheap. grella, michalik, schmeichal, gradel.

i agree with what hes doing with the club but where is the delph/gradel/schmeical money?? not to mention the revenue as its probably the most expensive ground for ticket prices.

Agree1 Disagree1

Ken Bates is more ofa plant pot than the flower pot men. I am not an expert in company law & i understand if you have been a director of a company that goes into bankrupcy you cannot be a director of another company for 7 years, so how has Bates managed it.

Agree0 Disagree1

There is more overheads to a football club than just players wages and transfer fees Re the money from player sales well if you beleive Grayson that its sat in a transfer kitty waiting for him to use it. Dont blame bates blame sg for not doing that.

Agree1 Disagree0

Re Leeds bankrupt Leeds did not go bankrupt they entered into administration the two are worlds apart and involve different terms on directors, Nic that you was trying to be smart, just not smart enough. Ken bates had to comply with Bates and the other directors obtained the permission of a court to act as directors of the new Leeds United Football Club Ltd, as required by s216 of the Insolvency Act.

Agree2 Disagree0

22 Dec 2011 13:55:16
States in Yorkshire Evening Post that Becchio failed to have a operation when he was supposed to and eventually had it over 2 months afterwards when he broke down in pre season. Instead of having the op Becchio decided to go to Spain. This then delayed his recovery and is the result of the first half of the season being limited to mainly substitution appearances as he has been recovering.
Whats your thoughts if this is true? Has he basically compromised our season or not? Does or current tactics / formation include him or not?

Believable0 Unbelievable1

Becchio isnt the hub of the team...ross played well til becchio came back so dont think it mattered too much at the beginning of the season, although I reckon he should have gone for the op sooner to give us more options at strat

Agree0 Disagree0

22 Dec 2011 11:38:25
Confirmed by KB that Grayson needs to deliver this season or he will be sacked.

Thank god for that at least we no by next season we will have another manager and then and only then leeds will get back to the prem.

www.thesun.co.uk/sol/homepage/sport/football/4014619/Simon-Grayson-I-fear-the-axe.html

Believable4 Unbelievable5

Confirmed by the sun lol

Agree4 Disagree1

Its also on SSN. This is pressure Grayson doesn't needs and who are we going to have that will get us to the Prem on a tight budget. If Grayson goes I can see the next few years a time where we have 2 or 3 managers as things will go wrong. We need to stay with 1 manager and keep building, if we miss Prem next this time then we will come back stronger next time. Keep the faith.

MOT

Agree4 Disagree2

Grayson is not the man for the job all he is building is a average squad and a split in the fans.

Agree6 Disagree2

Whether Grayson is the man for the job or not even the humble fan knows where our weaknesses are and without pumping cash in how the f**k does Bates think Grayson will improve? If you don't trust him get rid of him and give the new boss some cash, if you do want him then give him the money.

Agree4 Disagree0

Currently going into the festive period lying 6th in the league, with a so called average team is not bad going at all. lets see were we are at the end of the season,but for now get behind the team we all love. mot

Agree2 Disagree1

I hardly feel how commenting my true feeling on a Leeds banter page is an example of me not being behind the team. I’m a season ticket holder I'm not a so called arm chair fan, I’m not a so called fan that boos the team or sings and chants against bates and gets on the teams back so i feel it is acceptable to discuss my true thoughts on a discussion page with Leeds fans. I do not feel that Leeds are or will go anywhere under Grayson, I believe him to be tactically inept, he has made terrible media comments, he is at the helm of a split and divided dressing room, he has a squad of 28 players and the majority are average, he does not rotate the team, he has accepted publically that he has transfer finds to spend and that he has been given the money from player sales, he has a wage budget that is amongst the highest in the league he has an excellent youth system in place with quality players coming through can h nurture them, all in all the above gives me no confidence in Grayson as our manager, if he was so good why did Blackpool fans cheer when he went, why has he not been given a job in the premier league, why cant he sort out our defence, why does he play the long ball game, why does he sign journey men i.e. Brown and Miek Taylor rather than trust the youth players or sign a up and coming talented player these are all valid points and I have more but I will await the tinted brigades response to provide them.

Agree3 Disagree1

I like to know where these rumours of a split dressing room come from- just because some people say it doesn't make it true..or did you read that in the Sun? By the way Bates said the same thing three weeks ago..I wonder if those naughty little sun journalists with their unblemished characters are just stirring things up a bit. Grayson will either get us into the play odds is season, or he'll go. It doesn't take much to work that out, even for the average sun reader.

Agree1 Disagree1

Should be exciting the play odds we have never been there. Btw have a word with O'brien, Brown, Bruce, Bromby, Rachubka, Vayrynen, Nunez, Forsell, Becchi and ask them about the split Grayson has a first 11 and thats it.

Agree3 Disagree0

Have you asked them? Or did you read that somewhere else. Read this and believe it then: the world is flat...now spread it around and people like you will believe it's true!

Agree0 Disagree0

22 Dec 2011 11:27:40
Just waiting for ppls "inside information" on Leeds signing Nicky Maynard now he has been put up for sale, I know and you should all know Leeds won't be signing him, as much as I'd be happy for him to sign it's just unlikey, we would get out bidded on either fee and if not that then definitely on wages.

Believable0 Unbelievable1

No chance, Prem team or Leicester/Southampton as he will cost 2-3 million.

MOT

Agree1 Disagree2

Not southampton, they're sh**e and will finish 9th or 10th I assure you.

Agree3 Disagree2

From what I recall, they hammered us and im sure they are top of the league!

Agree2 Disagree1